Partner offer: the Free Gold & Silver IRA Info Kit from Augusta Precious MetalsGet it free

Stable Value and Money Market Funds in Retirement Plans: How They Differ

Updated November 19, 2026Facts checked against sources on November 19, 2026

The short answer

A money market fund is a type of mutual fund that holds short-term debt. A stable value fund is a plan option that uses insurance-type contracts to aim to protect principal. Neither is a bank deposit. The SEC says money market funds are not FDIC-guaranteed and can lose money.

Look at the investment menu in a 401(k) or similar plan and you may see a "money market fund" and a "stable value fund" side by side. Both are described as lower-volatility options. But they are built in different ways, and the protection behind each one is not the same. This guide explains the differences using SEC, Department of Labor, GAO and FDIC sources. It explains rules and trade-offs only. It does not say which one anyone should hold.

What is a money market fund?

A money market fund is a type of mutual fund. The SEC's Investor.gov site says these funds "invest in liquid, short-term debt securities, cash and cash equivalents" (Investor.gov, Money Market Funds).

Most of these funds try to keep their share price steady at $1.00. The SEC says they "seek to keep their NAV at a stable $1.00 per share." NAV means net asset value, the price of one share. The SEC also says that institutional prime and institutional tax-exempt funds use a floating price, so their share prices can rise or fall (SEC Investor Bulletin, Nov. 4, 2024).

The SEC describes some funds as built for individual investors and others, which "typically require high minimum investments," as built for institutions. The same bulletin says government money market funds "invest 99.5% or more of their total assets" in very liquid investments such as cash and government securities.

Are money market funds insured or guaranteed?

No. The SEC states that money invested in a money market fund "is not guaranteed by the FDIC like bank accounts are." It adds that there is a risk "you may lose some or all of the money you invested" (Investor.gov).

The SEC bulletin points out a few features that matter in a stress event:

  • Re-pricing. If a fund with a stable price drifts too far from $1.00, "the fund must re-price its shares to something other than $1.00."
  • Liquidity fees. A fund may charge a fee to investors who sell when many others are selling. The SEC says these fees "are designed to protect the remaining shareholders." Institutional prime and tax-exempt funds are generally required to charge them when daily net redemptions exceed 5% of net assets. For retail prime and retail tax-exempt funds, the bulletin says a fee applies when the fund's board or its delegate decides it is in the fund's best interest.
  • Suspending redemptions. The bulletin says funds are "permitted (but not required) to permanently suspend redemptions and liquidate" the fund.
  • Fees. Funds charge fees. The SEC says fees can be larger than a fund's income when short-term interest rates are very low, which can cause losses.

On the plus side, the SEC says money market funds are "redeemable on demand," so investors can generally sell shares on any business day at the fund's net asset value.

A note on names. A money market fund is not the same thing as a "money market deposit account" at a bank. The FDIC lists money market deposit accounts as insured deposits (FDIC, Your Insured Deposits). A money market fund is a mutual fund, and the FDIC says it does not insure mutual funds.

What is a stable value fund?

A stable value fund is an option offered inside some retirement plans. The Department of Labor's ERISA Advisory Council describes it as "a conservative, fixed income investment vehicle with an objective of preserving capital" (DOL Advisory Council, 2009). The GAO says these funds are "designed to preserve the total amount of participants' contributions, or their principal" (GAO-11-291).

The key feature is a contract. The GAO calls the wrap contract "a guarantee by a service provider, in the event of participant withdrawals, to pay participants at book value." Book value means what you put in plus the interest credited to you, not the day's market price of the bonds underneath. The Advisory Council's report says balances grow at the "crediting rate" promised by the fund provider.

Who backs a stable value fund?

Private companies stand behind the contract, not a government insurer. The GAO describes two main designs:

  • Traditional guaranteed investment contracts (GICs). The plan sponsor "contracts with an insurance company to guarantee participants principal protection and a rate of return."
  • Synthetic GICs, also called wrap contracts. The plan sponsor "contracts with a bank or insurance company to guarantee participants principal protection." The Advisory Council says wraps are bought from "banks, insurers, or other financial companies."

The guarantee has limits. The GAO says a wrap provider covers the difference between market value and book value. It also says that when market value is below book value, participants are at risk for losses, and a wrap contract voided by an employer-initiated event adds further exposure. It names other risks, such as a fund being left unwrapped if a provider leaves or is downgraded. A witness before the Advisory Council likewise said these funds are "not no-risk investments," because participants face interest rate risk and the credit risk of the issuer.

According to testimony summarized in the Advisory Council's report, book-value protection applies to transactions that participants start, such as moving money to other plan options or taking benefits. It lists employer-initiated events, such as plan terminations and employer bankruptcies, as situations where participants may not receive book value.

None of the sources we opened describes stable value funds as FDIC-insured. We found no FDIC statement about them either. If you want to know what stands behind your plan's fund, ask for its plan documents and fund fact sheet.

Can you move money from a stable value fund to a money market fund?

In some plans, no, or not right away. The GAO explains that a wrap contract may "prohibit them from transferring their assets into 'competing' investment options." Participants "may instead be required to put their assets into a noncompeting investment option for 90 days." The GAO says such restrictions are included to prevent participants from taking advantage of interest rate fluctuations.

Which funds count as "competing," and how long a wait applies, varies by plan. A witness before the Advisory Council also said wrap terms can limit a plan sponsor's ability to add new funds, including "a competing fund." Check your plan's rules before assuming you can move freely.

How do the two compare with bank accounts?

The table puts the main points side by side, based on the sources above.

Money market fundStable value fundBank savings account or CD
What it isA mutual fund holding short-term debt and cash equivalentsA plan option using insurance-type contracts to aim to preserve principalA deposit at a bank
Who stands behind itNo guarantee; the fund's holdings and SEC rules applyThe wrap or GIC issuer (a bank or insurer), under the contractThe bank
FDIC insured?No. The SEC says it is "not guaranteed by the FDIC"Not described as FDIC-insured in the sources we readYes, if the bank is FDIC-insured, up to the limit
Can you lose money?Yes. The SEC says you may lose some or all of your investmentYes, in some cases. The guarantee has limits (GAO)FDIC insurance covers deposits up to its limit at an insured bank
Price per shareAims for $1.00 in most funds; some floatBook value, credited at a stated rateNot applicable
Limits on moving moneyFees or suspension possible in stress"Competing fund" limits in some plansCDs may have terms set by the bank

We did not read bank CD early-withdrawal terms in a primary source, so the table says only that CD terms are set by the bank.

What does FDIC insurance actually cover?

The FDIC insures deposits up to "$250,000 per depositor, per ownership category at each FDIC-insured bank." Savings accounts, checking accounts, CDs and money market deposit accounts are on its covered list. Stocks, bonds, mutual funds and annuities are on its not-insured list (FDIC, Understanding Deposit Insurance).

For retirement accounts, the FDIC says traditional, Roth, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs fall into a "certain retirement accounts" category. Deposits in that category at the same bank are added together and insured up to $250,000 per owner (FDIC, Your Insured Deposits). This applies only to deposits, such as deposit accounts held in an IRA, and not to mutual funds held inside an IRA.

What is the inflation risk of cash-like holdings?

Inflation means prices rise over time, so each dollar buys less. The SEC says "inflation reduces purchasing power, which is a risk for investors receiving a fixed rate of interest," and "the principal concern for individuals investing in cash equivalents is that inflation will erode returns" (Investor.gov, What is Risk?). It describes a tradeoff between security and availability on one hand and a low interest rate on the other.

For readers aged 45 to 75 this matters because retirement can last decades. A holding that stays steady in dollars can still lose buying power. On the other side, holdings that move more can fall in value when you need the money. The sources do not tell anyone how to balance this. That depends on your goals, timeline, taxes and other income, and it is a question for a qualified financial professional. Our guides on how much you need to retire and retirement savings by age help frame the questions.

What mistakes do people make with these funds?

  • Treating "stable" or "money market" as "insured." The SEC says money market funds are not FDIC-guaranteed. Stable value protection comes from a contract with limits.
  • Mixing up a money market fund with a money market deposit account. They are different products with different protection.
  • Ignoring plan rules. Some plans limit transfers from stable value into competing funds. The rule is in your plan documents, not in this article.
  • Overlooking fees. The SEC says money market fund fees can exceed income when rates are very low.
  • Forgetting inflation. Steady dollar balances can still lose purchasing power.

Questions to take to a professional

  • Which stable value or money market options does my plan offer, and what are their fees and any transfer limits?
  • If I move money out of a stable value fund, are there "competing fund" rules or a waiting period?
  • How would a rollover change these options? See our comparison of an IRA vs a 401(k).
  • How much of my plan should be in cash-like holdings, given my timeline and inflation risk?

For the full series, see our retirement planning guide.

Where gold and silver IRAs fit - and where they do not

Money market and stable value funds aim for steadiness. Some savers also look at gold and silver. Reasons some savers give include diversification away from stocks and bonds and the appeal of holding a tangible asset. These are arguments, not promises, and this site makes no price forecast.

The costs and rules matter just as much. Prices can fall as well as rise, which our price volatility guide covers. Fees can apply, as described in our gold IRA fee guide. The IRS says an individually directed account's purchase of a collectible is treated as a distribution of its cost, and that "bullion of a certain fineness" is excluded only "if a bank or approved non-bank trustee keeps physical possession of it" (IRS collectibles page). See our gold IRA rules and risk guide, and the comparison of a gold IRA vs CDs. This site does not say whether metals suit any one person.

Sources

  1. Money Market Funds: Investor Bulletin, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov. Accessed Invalid Date.
  2. Money Market Funds, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov. Accessed Invalid Date.
  3. What is Risk?, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov. Accessed Invalid Date.
  4. 401(K) Plans: Certain Investment Options and Practices That May Restrict Withdrawals Not Widely Understood (GAO-11-291), U.S. Government Accountability Office. Accessed Invalid Date.
  5. 2009 Stable Value Funds and Retirement Security in the Current Economic Conditions, U.S. Department of Labor, ERISA Advisory Council. Accessed Invalid Date.
  6. Understanding Deposit Insurance, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Accessed Invalid Date.
  7. Your Insured Deposits, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Accessed Invalid Date.
  8. Investments in collectibles in individually directed qualified plan accounts, Internal Revenue Service. Accessed Invalid Date.

This guide is general education, not personalized financial, tax or legal advice. See our financial disclaimer, editorial policy and advertising disclosure.

Free Gold & Silver IRA Info KitGet it